I had gone looking for a missing person and found the edges of something darker. Part of me—the cautious part, the part that had kept me alive this long—whispered that Tom was right. Some stones should remain unturned.
But then there was the other part of me, the part that had scattered tarot cards across my table in frustration, the part that had never been able to leave a mystery unsolved.
That part was already walking toward the Diner, toward Sarah, toward whatever truth waited in the shadows of Mark Stevens’ disappearance.
Tom’s directions led me through a maze of New York streets where neon reflections rippled across rain-slicked pavement like fevered hallucinations. Each step toward the diner felt heavier than the last, my mind churning with possibilities, none of them pleasant. What kind of deal had Mark made? And with whom—or what? The rain had thinned to a misty drizzle that clung to my skin like cold sweat, transforming the urban landscape into something halfway between reality and nightmare. The diner appeared around a corner, its vintage sign a beacon of artificial normalcy in a night that felt increasingly unhinged.
The diner was an anachronism, a 1950s time capsule wedged between a pawnshop and a convenience store that advertised check cashing and lottery tickets in equal measure. The chrome exterior gleamed despite the grime of the city, and neon tubes outlined the windows in electric blue. Through the steamy glass, I could see scattered patrons hunched over plates and mugs, oblivious to the world outside their bubble of fluorescent light and comfort food.
I hesitated with my hand on the door. What was I doing here, really? Following a hunch? Chasing a ghost? Mister B.’s words echoed in my mind: The road you have to travel to get the information you want is an important part of your journey. Was this journey worth the destination? I still didn’t know, but I pushed through the door anyway, a small bell announcing my entrance with inappropriate cheer.
Inside, the diner enveloped me in warmth and the smell of coffee and grease. Red vinyl booths lined the walls, their surfaces cracked and mended with duct tape in places. The checkered floor, once black and white, had faded to gray and yellow under years of foot traffic. A jukebox in the corner played old rock ‘n’ roll, Elvis crooning about suspicious minds.
The handful of customers barely glanced my way. A couple of truckers at the counter, an old man with a newspaper, a woman with shopping bags piled beside her booth. No one who matched the description of Sarah that Tom had reluctantly provided: “Blonde. Pretty once. Looks like she’s carrying the weight of knowing too much.”
I scanned the room again and noticed a waitress refilling coffee at the counter. Her back was to me, but something in the slope of her shoulders spoke of defeat. Her blonde hair was pulled back in a ponytail that had begun to come undone, stray strands escaping like she no longer had the energy to contain them.
As if sensing my scrutiny, she turned. Her face confirmed what her posture had suggested—this was a woman haunted by absence. Shadows beneath her eyes hinted at sleepless nights, and there was a tightness around her mouth that spoke of words swallowed instead of spoken. Her nametag read “Sarah,” but I would have known her anyway. She wore her grief like other people wore jewelry—visible, defining.
Our eyes met across the diner. Something flickered across her face—recognition, perhaps, though we’d never met. Or maybe just the wariness of a woman who had learned to expect the worst.
I slid into an empty booth by the window. Sarah hesitated, then approached with a coffeepot and a forced smile that never reached her eyes.
“Coffee?” she asked, her voice thin but steady.
“Please.” I nodded, studying her face as she poured. Up close, the signs of strain were even more apparent—tiny lines at the corners of her eyes, chapped lips, fingernails bitten to the quick.
“Know what you want to order?” She produced a notepad from her apron pocket, pen poised.
“Just the coffee for now,” I said. Then, taking a chance: “And some information about Mark Stevens.”
The coffeepot trembled in her hand, a few drops spilling onto the table. Her face drained of what little color it had possessed.
“I don’t know anyone by that name,” she said, but the lie was transparent, her voice betraying her.
“Sarah.” I kept my tone gentle but firm. “I know he was your husband. I know he disappeared six months ago after a night in the casino.”
Her eyes darted around the diner, checking if anyone had overheard. The other patrons remained absorbed in their own concerns.
“Who are you?” she whispered, fear sharpening her features.
“My name is Rahel. I’m…” I hesitated, unsure how to define myself. “I’m someone who wants to find out what happened to Mark.”
“Are you police? Because they’ve already—”
“No,” I interrupted. “I’m not police. I’m just… looking for answers.”
“Why?” Suspicion narrowed her eyes. “What’s Mark to you?”
Another question I didn’t have a good answer for. I couldn’t explain my compulsion to investigate, the way Jack’s story had hooked into something inside me and wouldn’t let go.
“Let’s just say I have a professional interest in disappearances,” I said finally. “Especially ones that might not be entirely… natural.”
Something shifted in her expression—a flicker of recognition, perhaps. She glanced at the clock on the wall, then back at me.
“I’m due for a break in fifteen minutes,” she said, her voice low. “If you’re still here, maybe we can talk.”
I nodded, and she moved away to attend to other customers. I sipped the coffee, which was exactly what you’d expect from a place like this—weak, slightly bitter, served in a chipped white mug that had seen better decades. The jukebox switched to a Buddy Holly song, its upbeat tempo creating an uncomfortable juxtaposition with the conversation to come.
Fifteen minutes crawled by. I watched Sarah move through the diner, taking orders, delivering plates, smiling emptily at customers. She performed her duties like an automaton, going through motions that her body remembered while her mind dwelled elsewhere.
Eventually, she slid into the booth across from me, removing her apron and folding it neatly on the seat beside her. Close up, I could see that her uniform had been washed so many times that its original blue had faded to the color of a winter sky.
“I only have twenty minutes,” she said, her voice barely audible over the diner’s ambient noise. “And I don’t know what I can tell you that I haven’t already told the police.”
“Sometimes it’s not about saying something new,” I replied. “Sometimes it’s about saying it to someone who’s listening differently.”
A flicker of something—hope, perhaps—crossed her face before she suppressed it. “What do you want to know?”
“Tell me about Mark. Who he was. What happened before he disappeared.”
Sarah’s hands fidgeted with a paper napkin, folding and unfolding it compulsively. “Mark was… complicated. Brilliant but restless. Never satisfied.” A ghost of a smile touched her lips. “We met here, actually. He came in for coffee every morning for a week before he got up the nerve to ask me out.”
“He was a poker player?”
“Among other things.” She shrugged slightly. “He bounced between jobs. Delivery driver, bookstore clerk, bartender for a while. But poker was his passion. He had a gift for it.”
“Was he winning before he disappeared?”
Her fingers stilled on the napkin. “Yes and no. He’d been on a losing streak for months. We were behind on rent, on bills. He was getting desperate.” She swallowed hard. “Then suddenly, he started winning again. Big.”
“Just like that? His luck changed?”
Sarah’s eyes met mine, and I saw fear there, old and familiar. “He said he’d found an edge. A system. I didn’t ask questions because we needed the money, but…” She trailed off.
“But?” I prompted.
“He changed,” she whispered. “Subtle things at first. He stopped wearing the cross his mother gave him. Severing ties with his brother. Started keeping odd hours. Sometimes I’d wake up at night and find him sitting in the dark, just staring at nothing.”
A chill that had nothing to do with the diner’s air conditioning crept up my spine. “Did he say anything about making a deal?”
Her head snapped up, eyes wide. “How did you—” She stopped herself. “The night before he disappeared, he came home late. He’d been drinking, but he wasn’t drunk. There was this… energy about him. Feverish. He kept saying he’d found a solution, that tomorrow would change everything.”
“Did he explain?”
“Not really. Just fragments. Something about knowing which cards would come. About seeing through the backs.” She looked down at her hands. “I thought it was just talk, you know? Then he said something that stuck with me. He said, ‘Every deal has its price, Sarah. I just hope I can afford this one.’”
The paper napkin in her hands had been reduced to shreds. I watched her fingers continue to tear at the pieces, creating smaller and smaller fragments.
“The next night he went to the casino, to win big. Bigger than at the bars he was at usually,” she continued. “He kissed me goodbye, said he’d be home late, not to wait up. Told me everything was going to be better soon.” Her voice cracked slightly. “I never saw him again.”
The jukebox had fallen silent, the diner suddenly too quiet. In the lull, I could hear the soft hiss of rain against the windows and the rhythmic ticking of the clock above the counter.
“The police?” I asked.
Sarah’s laugh was hollow. “They took a report. Talked to some people at Lucky's. To casino security. But Mark had disappeared before—just for a day or two, when he was on a gambling streak or when we fought. They thought…” She shook her head. “They thought he’d won big and left. Left the city. Left me.”
“But you don’t believe that.”
“No.” The word was firm, certain. “Something happened to him. Something bad.”
I believed her. Not just because of what Tom had told me, or the strange pull I’d felt when Jack first mentioned Mark’s name. I believed her because the conviction in her voice matched the dread in my gut.
“Did Mark leave anything behind? Something personal, something that might help me… understand him better?”
Sarah studied me, her gaze unexpectedly penetrating. “Why are you really doing this? What’s your angle?”
I considered lying, then decided against it. “I don’t have an angle. I just… when I hear about disappearances like Mark’s, I can’t let them go.” I met her eyes directly. “Sometimes I see things others miss. Sometimes I can help when conventional methods fail.”
She held my gaze for a long moment, then reached into her uniform pocket and withdrew two items: a folded photograph and what appeared to be a poker chip.
“His lucky chip,” she said, sliding them across the table. “And the last picture I took of him. He always carried this chip—said it was from his first big win. The night he disappeared was the first time he’d gone to a game without it.”
I picked up the photograph first. It showed a man in his late thirties, dark-haired and intense, with a half-smile that suggested he was privy to a joke no one else understood. There was something magnetic about his eyes, a quality that pulled you in while simultaneously keeping you at a distance.
The poker chip was old, its edges worn smooth from handling. Casino markings had faded to near invisibility, but as I turned it over in my fingers, I felt an unexpected warmth, as if it retained some essence of its former owner.
“He left it behind deliberately?” I asked, looking up from the chip.
Sarah nodded. “Said he wouldn’t need luck anymore. That he had something better.” A tear escaped, tracking down her cheek. She wiped it away quickly. “I don’t know what that meant. I still don’t.”
Our eyes met across the table, and in that moment, something passed between us—an unspoken acknowledgment of the darkness that had touched both our lives, though in different ways.
“I should get back to work,” she said, glancing at the clock.
“Can I keep these?” I asked, indicating the photograph and chip.
She hesitated, then nodded. “For now. But I want them back.”
“Of course.” I slipped both items into my coat pocket. “If I find anything…”
“Don’t make promises,” she interrupted, suddenly fierce. “Everyone promises. The police. Mark. Even myself.” She stood, retying her apron with quick, practiced movements. “Just do what you can, or don’t. But don’t promise.”
I nodded, understanding. Sarah gave me one last look, as if memorizing my face in case she needed to identify me later, then returned to her post behind the counter.
I left money for the coffee on the table and slid out of the booth. The diner’s warmth suddenly felt suffocating, its nostalgic charm a thin veneer over something rotten. I needed air, needed to think.
As I pushed through the door, the bell jangled again, its cheerfulness now seeming like mockery. The photograph and poker chip weighed heavy in my pocket, physical anchors to a mystery that grew deeper with each revelation.
I stepped out of the diner into a cold, unyielding night. The rain had stopped, but the air hung heavy with moisture, clinging to my skin like the remnants of a bad dream. The streetlight above buzzed with electric uncertainty, its yellow glow carving the world into harsh shadows and sickly illumination. I stood motionless on the sidewalk, feeling the weight of the photograph and poker chip in my pocket—physical evidence of a man who had vanished like smoke, leaving behind only questions and the hollow space of absence.
My fingers sought out these tangible clues, drawing them into the stuttering light. The photograph first—its edges softened by handling, a crease running diagonally across one corner where it had been folded and unfolded too many times. Mark Stevens stared back at me with eyes that seemed to know things, to see beyond the moment captured by the camera. Not handsome in the conventional sense, but magnetic. The kind of face that made you want to lean closer, to listen more carefully. I studied his features, committing them to memory: the slight asymmetry of his smile, the intensity in his gaze, the way his dark hair fell across his forehead with deliberate carelessness.
Was there something in his expression that hinted at what was to come? Some prescience of his own disappearance? Or was I only seeing what I wanted to see, finding patterns?
I turned the photo over. Nothing written on the back, no date, no location. Just blank white space, as empty of answers as everything else in this case.
Next, the poker chip. My thumb traced its circumference, feeling the smooth edges worn down by Mark’s own touch. It was green—or had been once, before time and handling had faded it. The casino markings were ghosts, barely visible impressions of lettering and numbers. I tilted it under the streetlight, trying to make out the name, but it remained illegible, a secret kept.
What had made this particular chip “lucky”? And why had Mark, after carrying it faithfully through countless games, left it behind on the night he disappeared? The night he claimed he “had something better than luck.”
The chip felt unnaturally warm against my skin, as if it retained some echo of Mark’s body heat, some residual energy from the countless times he’d turned it over in his fingers, a tactile talisman. Or perhaps the warmth came from within me, a physical manifestation of the connection I was forming to this mystery, to this man I’d never met.
I pocketed both items again, these fragments of a stranger’s life now entrusted to me. The street around me was quiet except for the distant sounds of traffic and the occasional drip of water from overhanging eaves. A mangy cat slunk across the road, pausing to regard me with luminous eyes before disappearing into an alley.
What had I learned? Mark Stevens, a man with a gift for cards. A restless soul who bounced between jobs but found his true calling at the poker table. A man who’d been losing, desperate, until something changed. Until he claimed to have found an “edge”—a way to see through the backs of cards. Until he’d made some kind of deal.
The deal. That was the thread that connected everything, the dark center around which this mystery revolved. Tom’s account of Mark’s drunken confession. Sarah’s memory of his cryptic words: “Every deal has its price. I just hope I can afford this one.”
What kind of deal grants the ability to know which cards will come? What kind of deal ends with a man vanishing without a trace? My mind supplied answers, each more unsettling than the last. Deals with loan sharks. Deals with criminals. Deals with…
I stopped myself. I dealt in facts, in evidence, not in the supernatural possibilities that hovered at the edges of my consciousness. And yet, there was something about this case that pulled at that other part of me, the part that scattered tarot cards and spoke to spirits.
The King of Swords appeared in my mind’s eye, his stern face and gleaming blade a reminder of the path forward: clear thinking, intellectual power, truth. Not intuition. Not fear. Not the cold fingers of dread that traced my spine when I thought about what might have happened to Mark Stevens.
A sudden gust of wind sent a discarded newspaper skittering across the pavement, pages flapping like wounded birds. I pulled my coat tighter, though the chill I felt seemed to come from within rather than without.
What was my next step? I could try to track down the men from the poker game, the ones in expensive suits with cheap smiles. I could revisit Lucky's, see if there were other regulars who might remember details Tom had forgotten or omitted. I could investigate the back room where high-stakes games were played, search for physical evidence the police might have missed.
Or I could do what I did best: listen to the spaces between words, the silences that spoke louder than confessions. Maybe Mister B. would have insights, if I could coax him into appearing again. Maybe the cards would be more forthcoming now that I had tangible connections to Mark.
“I must know your secrets,” I whispered, my breath fogging in the cold air. The words weren’t directed at anyone or anything in particular—Mark, the poker chip, the universe, myself. All had secrets I needed to uncover.
Across the street, a neon sign for a bail bonds office flickered erratically, its blue-white glow casting strange patterns across the wet pavement. As I watched, the light seemed to warp and shift, forming shapes that were almost familiar before dissolving again. For a disorienting moment, the shapes resembled playing cards scattered across a table, then faces contorted in anguish, then nothing but random pulses of electricity.
I blinked hard, dispelling the illusion. Lack of sleep and an overactive imagination—a dangerous combination in my line of work. I needed to stay grounded, focused. The King of Swords would accept nothing less.
And yet, as I turned down a narrow side street that would lead me back toward my apartment, I couldn’t shake the feeling that I was being watched. Not by human eyes, perhaps, but by something else—something that had taken notice of my interest in Mark Stevens. Something that had made a deal and collected payment.
The sensation of invisible scrutiny prickled between my shoulder blades, but I refused to turn around, to show fear. Instead, I walked with deliberate steps, one hand in my pocket where my fingers curled protectively around the photograph and poker chip.
Whatever had happened to Mark Stevens, whatever dark bargain he’d struck, I was now part of the equation. The mystery had hooks in me, barbed and deep. I couldn’t turn back if I wanted to—and I didn’t want to. Not yet. Not until I understood what kind of deal could give a man the ability to see through cards, and what kind of price could erase him from existence.
Ahead, the street narrowed further, buildings leaning in as if listening to my thoughts. Shadows pooled in doorways and recesses, deeper than they should have been, almost liquid in their darkness. I pushed forward, my footsteps echoing off brick and concrete, each sound a defiant announcement of my presence.
Let whatever was watching, watch. Let it know I was coming. Let it know I wouldn’t stop until I uncovered the truth about Mark Stevens and the deal he’d made.
The truth, after all, was what I dealt in. Even when it came wrapped in shadow and whispered in voices that didn’t belong to human throats.
Even when it terrified me.
10Please respect copyright.ＰＥＮＡＮＡbFY0KWplR4
Originally, the whole chapter carried the name "The Widow's Story", but when I first released it, I soon started doubting myself. It had 6.570 words, way more than my other chapters and way more than what is common here on royal road. As it had 2 points where it could be naturally split, I thought, well, okay, maybe split it in 3. Hope that's okay for y'all :)
If you like to continue reading immediately, you can of course do so on Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/RahelVega
I'm always curious what you think, please leave me a comment, that means a lot to me :)
ns216.73.216.89da2
and then Add to home screen.